How should Texas Select its Judges?

You are the chairperson for a committee to consider a new system of selecting
state judges in Texas. Your committee has studied the research above and is
writing a recommendation to the state as to how Texas should select its judges.
Now, you will write a report to the Governor, state legislature, and citizens of
Texas to explain your committee’s decision.
Answer & Explanation
VerifiedSolved by verified expert
The method by which Texas selects its judges has been a topic of debate for many years. Currently, Texas uses a system of partisan elections to select judges at all levels of the state judiciary. However, there are several alternative methods that Texas could use to select its judges, including:

Appointment: In this system, judges would be appointed by the governor or some other official, rather than elected by the public. This method is used in many other states and has the advantage of being less susceptible

Looking for a similar assignment?

Let Us write for you! We offer custom paper writing services

Place your order

Step-by-step explanation
to the influence of special interests and campaign financing.

Merit Selection: Under this system, a nominating committee would evaluate candidates based on their qualifications and experience, and then make recommendations to the governor or other appointing authority. The goal is to select judges who are qualified, experienced, and impartial.

Retention Elections: In this system, judges are initially appointed by the governor or some other authority, but are subject to periodic retention elections in which voters decide whether to keep them in office or not. This method is used in several states and provides a compromise between appointment and election systems.

Each of these methods has its advantages and disadvantages, and the best approach will depend on the specific needs and values of the state. Ultimately, the goal should be to ensure that judges are selected based on their qualifications, experience, and impartiality, rather than their ability to win a popularity contest or appeal to a particular constituency.

Download PDF